In the late 70s, two ad men met for an informal chat that will set the wheels of history as we know it in motion. This meeting of minds isn’t based on a singular event that really happened. It’s an example of the strategy meetings marketing directors and lobbyists have had about maintaining non-renewable energy as the world’s primary energy source, even when facts show doing so will lead to a mass death sentence.
What saves the production from being immersive education is writer, director and one of the two performers Christopher Samuel Carroll’s exploration of how ‘faceless men’, like the two we’re given access to, can live with knowing the damage they’re doing to themselves, their loved ones and a few billion other people.
Carroll’s writing is witty and engaging, keeping audiences intrigued through the play’s introduction where the two men exchange pleasantries across a mid-century meeting room as they size each other up. It starts to drag when Carroll’s character, working for a fuel company, keeps throwing up reasons why the tobacco industry is doomed to fail, while performer Damon Baudin, a hot shot marketing contractor working for the tobacco industry, keeps lobbying back.
When the fuel company’s research on the effects of carbon dioxide on the atmosphere is revealed, we find ourselves in the emotional meat of the play’s marketing-industry-critique sandwich. Carroll is fraught with guilt; Baudin is callously excited by the possibility of manipulating people on a global scale. Their heated back and forth is gripping and full of tension, but Carroll takes the energy back to zero by having Baudin translate the strategy he already outlined.
This is frustratingly repetitive; there’s no time allocated to flesh out his reflections about why people manipulate society to their own – and the collective’s – detriment.
Smokescreen: strong
Both actors deliver strong performances, though Baudin being a despicable character, is more fun to watch. Considering he wears three hats, Caroll has done a wonderful job in this production, but his directing is the weakest of the roles. There’s not much happening on stage bar subtle lighting changes that don’t appear to correlate with the dialogue. The emphasis is on Carroll’s writing and the exchange of ideas between the two characters. It’s fortunate the writing is strong enough that, apart from the moments of repetitive arguments, the talking heads format still keeps one’s attention.
Read: Book review: The Haunting of Mr & Mrs Stevenson, Belinda Lyons-Lee
Smokescreen is an exposé of how we can be manipulated by corporate interests but it only briefly touches on the far more interesting reflection of our capacity to undertake work that harms ourselves and others. However, the nuggets of commentary Carroll does deliver on this point are enough to make the show worth a watch.
Smokescreen
fortyfivedownstairs
Bare Witness Theatre Company
Writer/Director: Christopher Samuel Carroll
Lighting Designer: Antony Hateley and Ash Basham
Cast: Christopher Samuel Carroll and Damon Baudin
Tickets: $35-$45
Smokescreen will be performed until 13 July 2025.
Discover more arts, games and screen reviews on ArtsHub and ScreenHub.
Also on ArtsHub:
My Cousin Frank review: Rhoda Roberts engages at Arts Centre Melbourne
Francis ‘Frank’ Roberts made history in 1964 when he became the first Aboriginal to represent Australia at the Olympics. It is a sad indictment of the time that he had to travel under a British passport as a subject because he was not considered an Australian citizen. The struggles and triumphs of Frank are both personal and a reflection of those of his people. My Cousin Frank brings his story and the history that shaped it to life in a compelling production.
Rhonda Roberts AO tells the story of ‘Honest Frank’ in a wonderfully engaging style. It feels like you’ve been invited into her home to have a cup of tea and a chat about her cousin. There were a few nerves at the start of opening night, but as the show warmed up Roberts’ natural storytelling skill shone through. Roberts interweaves her cousin’s biography with anecdotes about other family members and historical background. Her narrative is supported by a projection of photographs and videos that bring the people in the story to life. Read more …
