Slush pile success stories

Among the pile of unsolicited manuscripts, occasionally a couple will be picked up for publication. Here are some stories of the lucky ones.

It’s the stuff of dreams, you send off your unsolicited manuscript to one or more coveted publishing houses and, after a few months of silence (in some cases even sooner!), your work is picked up from the hundreds of others languishing in the mountainous slush pile, to begin its long journey to publication. Out of the many unsuccessful pitches to sieve through, occasionally publishers find gold. ArtsHub speaks to a number of authors and publishers about the lucky happenstance when a manuscript finds a home.

Natasha Sholl, meanwhile, ultimately had success with Ultimo Press, also for her debut book, a memoir, Found, Wanting. She originally set up a potential publisher spreadsheet to record the entire submission process. ‘No one hates Excel more than me, but it gave me some distance from the process (and the illusion of control). My theory was that if I had a rejection, it wouldn’t sting as much if I had a potential “yes” still in the works. It also meant that if a publisher requested the full manuscript, in the next cover letter I would include a note that Publisher X had requested the manuscript and it was now on general submission. It’s important for transparency, but a bit of FOMO can’t hurt either.’  

Unlock Padlock Icon

Unlock this content?

Access this content and more

Thuy On is the former Reviews and Literary Editor of ArtsHub and an arts journalist, critic and poet who’s written for a range of publications including The Guardian, The Saturday Paper, Sydney Review of Books, The Australian, The Age/SMH and Australian Book Review. She was the Books Editor of The Big Issue for 8 years and a former Melbourne theatre critic correspondent for The Australian. She has three collections of poetry published by the University of Western Australian Press (UWAP): Turbulence (2020), Decadence (2022) and Essence (2025). Threads: @thuy_on123 Instagram: poemsbythuy