Premature adulation — The Weiss Scandal

Theater critic Hedy Weiss sparked outrage in September with a review of works in development the best in the business called “unfair” and outrageous. So what is the role of the critic when it comes to new work? Is Weiss typical or atypical of America’s ‘critic mass’?
[This is archived content and may not display in the originally intended format.]
Artshub Logo

It has long been the practice that theatrical critics remain silent during the early, developmental stages of a new theatrical work, not printing a word, positive or negative, until an official opening has occurred. But Hedy Weiss, critic for the Chicago Sun-Times, recently broke this unspoken-but-understood rule when she reviewed eight works-in-progress at a 30-year-old theater company called Theater Building Chicago, an organization dedicated to the development of original musicals.

For 13 years Theater Building Chicago has presented a weekend-long festival of musicals in progress, called Stages. In the early years, critics were explicitly asked not to review the unfinished products. Recently, however, it seems that this request has been anything but explicit.

Unlock Padlock Icon

Unlock this content?

Access this content and more

Howard Emanuel
About the Author
As an actor, Howard Emanuel has appeared across the USA in regional theatres ranging from The Paper Mill Playhouse and The Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey to the Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera and Houston's Theatre Under The Stars. As a playwright, he has recently completed his first full-length work, Last Supper. As a novelist, his urban fiction manuscript, Naked Angels, is currently being shopped to various publishing houses. He is currently hard at work on his second and third plays. He holds a B.F.A. in Acting from New York University, Tisch School of the Arts.