Natalie Bassingthwaighte leads all-star cast in Australian premiere of hit musical Waitress

Waitress, Broadway's sweetest hit gets a slice of Aussie star power, with Natalie Bassingthwaighte among the stars joining the cast.
Rob Mills, Mackenzie Dunn, Natalie Bassinthwaighte, Gabriyel Thomas, John Waters join cast of Waitress. Image: Peter Brew-Bevan.

Musical theatre fanatics have been hotly anticipating the Australian premiere of Broadway’s smash-hit musical Waitress, which opens at Melbourne’s Her Majesty’s Theatre from 1 May and the Sydney Lyric Theatre from 1 August.

Now, in a slice of news that comes fresh and hot out of the oven, Crossroads Live Producer John Frost has today announced the performers who will make up the show’s Down Under cast – and this line-up is all killer, no (pie) filler.

Meet the Australian cast of Waitress

Leading the cast as our leading lady – playing Jenna, an unhappily married waitress in a small US town – will be Aussie darling of the stage and screen Natalie Bassingthwaighte (Chicago, Shirley Valentine).

Something's cookin' with Natalie Bassinthwaighte, Gabriyel Thomas and Mackenzie Dunn, joining the Australian cast of Waitress. Photo: Peter Brew-Bevan.
Something’s cookin’ with Natalie Bassinthwaighte, Gabriyel Thomas and Mackenzie Dunn. Photo: Peter Brew-Bevan.

Playing Becky and Dawn, Jenna’s co-workers at the diner, will be Gabriyel Thomas, who comes direct from her acclaimed performance as Grizabella in the national tour of Cats, and Mackenzie Dunn, most recently seen on stage as Lily St Regis in the Australian tour of Annie.

Rob Mills (& Juliet), star of stage and screen (and the hearts of anyone who was there for the first season of Australian Idol), also joins the cast as Jenna’s endearing but neurotic gynaecologist Dr Pomatter, while legendary actor John Waters (The Woman in Black, Play School, All Saints) will be Joe, the curmudgeonly diner owner who has a soft spot for Jenna.

Waitress cast Rob Mills, Natalie Bassinthwaighte and John Waters
Rob Mills, Natalie Bassinthwaighte and John Waters are ready to slice it up. Photo: Peter Brew-Bevan.

It’s good to be Bass

A prolific leading lady of the stage, the screen and the music charts, Bassingthwaighte (aka ‘our Nat Bass’) is on a roll lately. She’s having a Bassingth-naissance, if you will.

From entering the public conscience as Izzy Holland on Neighbours (a role she recently reprised in the second season of Network Ten’s spinoff series, The Wrong Girl) to topping the ARIA Album Charts, Bassingthwaighte was most recently lauded for her performance on stage in the title role of last year’s Australian tour of Shirley Valentine.

Prior to this, she captivated audiences with her raw performance as Mary-Jane in Alanis Morissette’s Tony Award-winning musical Jagged Little Pill, earning a nomination for the prestigious Green Room Award for Best Leading Artist. Her many memorable characters in the world of musical theatre also include Roxie in Chicago, Sandy in Grease and Florence Vassy in Chess.

Here come the drums, here come the drums…

In addition to her starring role in Waitress, this year will also see 50-year-old Bassingthwaighte getting back to her electro-rock roots as the frontwoman of The Rogue Traders – with the MTV-award-winning, UK-chart-topping, break-out Aussie band reuniting for a national 21st anniversary tour that will be sure to have millennials across the country getting down to Voodoo Child.

Also coming in 2026 is the release of Bassingthwaighte’s memoir, Love Like This, which promises to ‘reflect on her personal and professional life with vulnerability, offering readers a powerful insight into the experiences that have shaped her both in and away from the spotlight’. (Presumably, this will also offer new insights into her experience of ‘coming out’ in 2023, when she revealed that she was in a ‘beautiful relationship with a woman’.)

Waitress the musical: a recipe for success

Waitress is the irresistible musical hit about resilience, friendship and hope that has captured hearts worldwide. Inspired by Adrienne Shelly’s beloved film, the show made history on Broadway with the four top creative spots being filled by women – with the trailblazing creative team seeing music and lyrics by Grammy-winner Sara Bareilles (Love Song, Brave), book by acclaimed screenwriter Jessie Nelson, direction by Tony-winner Diane Paulus, and choreography by Lorin Latarro.

This heartwarming and empowering musical tells the story of Jenna, a small-town waitress and expert pie maker who longs to escape her rocky marriage and start again. When a baking contest, an unexpected new romance and the support of her fellow waitresses offer her a taste of change, Jenna discovers that the secret ingredient to happiness might be closer than she ever imagined.

It opened on Broadway in April of 2016 at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre, where it ran until January 2020. Sweet, sassy and soul-stirring, Waitress is a feel-good celebration of second chances, and the magic of a well-made pie.

The Australian production of Waitress will light up Her Majesty’s Theatre, Melbourne from 1 May, before travelling to the Sydney Lyric Theatre from 1 August.

Discover more screen, games and arts news and reviews on ScreenHub and ArtsHub. Sign up for our free ArtsHub and ScreenHub newsletters.

Alannah Sue is a writer, editor, theatre critic and content creator with a passion for arts and culture and all that glitters. She relocated to Melbourne in 2025 after spending over a decade embedded in the Sydney arts landscape and finishing up her tenure as Arts & Culture Editor at Time Out. In addition to contributing to ArtsHub and ScreenHub, her freelance portfolio also expands to editorial and copywriting for lifestyle and arts publications such as Limelight and Urban List, cultural institutions like the Sydney Opera House, and marketing and publicity services for independent artists. She is always keen to take a chance on weird performance art, theatre of all kinds, out-of-the-box exhibitions, queer venues, and cheap Prosecco. Give her half a chance, and she will get on a soapbox when it comes to topics like the magic of musical theatre, the importance of rigorous arts criticism, and the global cultural implications of the RuPaul’s Drag Race franchise. Connect with Alannah on Instagram: @alannurgh.