Reviews

Rating : 3.5 stars

TV: Hamish and Andy's 'Perfect' Holiday

The amiable mates follow their reliable recipe for spontaneous comedy.
TV: Hamish and Andy's 'Perfect' Holiday Pranking good fun. Hamish and Andy, image courtesy NINE.

Anthony Morris

Tuesday 19 November, 2019

A decade or so ago, Australian comedy was booming. Chris Lilley was a ratings smash; shows like Spicks & Specks and Rove provided popular showcases for experienced comics and up-and-comers. Two of the fastest rising stars were Hamish Blake and Andy Lee, going from late night radio gigs and community television to a prime-time television series and a nationally syndicated radio show in a handful of years.

Ten years later and everyone they came up with is gone; even their former boss Rove couldn’t keep a talk show on air in 2019. They’re pretty much the only comedy performers left on Australian commercial television. What’s their secret?

ADVERTISEMENT

Watching Hamish and Andy’s “Perfect” Holiday, you’d be forgiven for thinking the answer was “don’t change a thing”. They first made a name for themselves on television with their segments on Rove performing various pranks and challenges, and this series sees them… performing various pranks and challenges. Their long-running Caravan of Courage and Gap Year series were all about them travelling across other countries, and this series is all about them… travelling across other countries.

So is the secret “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”? To be fair, it’s not like overseas prank trips are all they ever do. Their last series for Nine, True Story with Hamish and Andy, went in a different direction entirely as it re-enacted bizarre but true stories told by average Australians. And both Hamish and Andy have appeared as regulars on other shows in 2019, Hamish on LEGO Masters, Andy as a panellist on Talkin’ ‘bout Your Generation.

More importantly, pranks aren't something they just stumbled on. Early in their career they tried a variety of formats, most of which failed to click. Their 2004 Channel Seven series which saw them hosting a traditional sketch show was axed after two episodes; 2006 sketch series Real Stories had its moments, but wasn’t exactly a hit. Even their first Gap Year series for Nine had an odd Tonight Show feel to it early on, complete with celebrity interviews.

Pranks weren’t new ground for comedy in the ‘00s. The US series Jackass had been a global hit, creating a number of spin-offs and movies. What Hamish & Andy played up was the friendship between the two performers: they may have been constantly setting each other one up, but there was rarely any sense of real meanness behind it. They were – and are – just two mates messing around.

Their own personal charm clearly plays a role in their success, especially when the pranks take a while to get to the good part. When Perfect Holiday has Andy drive a bus while Hamish laughs, it’s only fun if you’re already invested in the rivalry between Hamish and Andy (the later bus race was a lot more entertaining). Hamish melting down while taking on the world’s hottest chilli was probably the high point; Andy getting a Vegemite-flavoured revenge on someone who’d given him a bloody nose on Hamish and Andy’s Gap Year was entertainingly petty.

But the big advantage of pranks over scripted comedy is that they feel spontaneous. The audience is watching something happening right in front of them. Over the last decade as reality television has overwhelmed pretty much everything else on the commercial networks, spontaneous has become an essential selling point.

Hamish and Andy are a charming comedy duo, and Hamish and Andy’s “Perfect” Holiday is perfectly entertaining television. But the reason they’ve lasted doing comedy on commercial television when everybody else has fallen by the wayside is almost entirely down to the fact that pranks are comedy’s version of reality television. And reality television is pretty much all that Australian commercial networks make now.

 
3.5 stars
★★★☆

Hamish and Andy’s “Perfect” Holiday
Director: Tim Bartley
Producers: Tim Bartley, Hamish Blake, Andy Lee, Ryan Shelton
Australia, 2019, 3 episodes
Premiered: November 17, 7pm on NINE.

About the author

Anthony Morris is a freelance film and television writer. He’s been a regular contributor to The Big IssueEmpire MagazineJunkeeBroadsheetThe Wheeler Centre and Forte Magazine, where he’s currently the film editor. Other publications he’s contributed to include ViceThe VineKill Your Darlings (where he was their online film columnist), The Lifted BrowUrban Walkabout and Spook Magazine. He’s the co-author of hit romantic comedy novel The Hot Guy, and he’s also written some short stories he’d rather you didn’t mention.

You can follow him on Twitter @morrbeat and read some of his reviews on the blog It’s Better in the Dark.