News, analysis and comment - performing arts 

REVIEW: Porcelain

By Yuhan Lim ArtsHub | Friday, January 25, 2008

  

Set in 90s Britain, Porcelain was Chay Yew’s first play, although not first produced. Exploring the isolation of a double minority – a gay Asian in a Caucasian society – Porcelain’s protagonist, John Lee, channels the rage, the isolation and highlights the not-so-subtle racism of the gay community.

It is hard not to feel that there is a lot of Yew himself in the character, and for me personally parts of the play came out a little high handed. Over the course of several confrontational conversations John has with his psychologist, John’s character invariably has the witty comeback, the sharply cutting line or the biting insight – and while it certainly builds his character as an isolated man nursing his emotional scars, at moments it appeared to break past characterisation into the mind of the author, sniping back at the personification of the white, gay men of the 1990s.

The narrative explores the otherness of the gay Asian in a time when a single Asian face in a gay magazine was a novelty. The usage of the word ‘Oriental’, the frustration of John’s immigrant father wondering whether he should have stayed in Hong Kong, and John’s desperation at feeling continually unwanted by the attractive white men surrounding him all mesh together to form a very believable picture of a man pushed to breaking point.

Perhaps more importantly, Yew very cleverly makes us care about the characters of Porcelain, drawing us in with characters the audience can identify with – be it John, his former lover William Hope or the drunken, anger filled psychologist, all gutsy roles compellingly performed by the cast. Keith Brockett, dressed all in white (the Chinese colour of mourning, and the western colour of innocence) stands out from his fellow actors, and truly embodies the tenuous societal position of John Lee – unwelcome in the Asian community but unwanted, if accepted, as part of Britain’s gay community, and driven to the public toilets as the only place where he ever feels desired by other men.

Drawing the audience in with a comical discussion about ‘cottaging’ that is reminiscent of Monty Python’s ‘Travel Agent’ skit, Porcelain grabs hold of the audience and using multiple narrators and intercutting flashback dialogue with voxpops and parables, it never lets the audience get comfortable, forcing one to question the validity and the reality of what is being portrayed. Perhaps not being strongly connected to the gay scene I’m the wrong Asian to comment on that – within my circle of rather geeky friends race is one of the last things noticed. However, Garrie Maguire, curator of Midsumma’s Men Like Me, insists racism is still alive and all too strong in the gay community, citing his exhibition as the only visual arts exhibition that failed to attract the “usual Midsumma arts crowd” to its launch. The theme is Asian men as photographed by other Asian men.

Regardless of how representative Porcelain is of the current situation, it certainly forces the issue with its audience, forces each member to consider how much of the existing racial discrimination they are responsible for, either as perpetrator or as a victim nursing early hurts to the point where engagement proves impossible even when offered. I do wonder however, how much it does to promote understanding and engagement with the subculture it represents however. While it lambastes the cultural zoo and fetishism of Asians, in going out of its way to explain Asian culture – in this case Sadako Sasaki’s one thousand paper cranes – it loses an opportunity to leave an unanswered question in the minds of those audience members who do not know of the story, and increase the resonance of the story with those who do. Leaving the question unanswered would also increase dialogue around the issues the play raises, which could only be a good thing.

Overall, Porcelain is a slick and thought provoking production, beautifully directed and acted – special mention must go to Keith Brockett’s commitment to the role of John Lee, a very difficult character to bring to life, and to Colin MacPherson’s Psychologist, another tough role, although his American accent has a tendency to default to his native Canadian on occasion. The set is simple, lighting effective – and perhaps by the end of the season, there will be one thousand paper cranes.

Porcelain runs until February 10 at La Mama Theatre, Melbourne
For more information, visit www.midsumma.org.au or www.lamama.com.au

Yuhan Lim

With a nine year hiatus spent in Hong Kong and Singapore, Yuhan is frequently caught off balance by the gaps in his knowledge about Australiana - gaps which invariably frustrate any hopes he entertains about appearing on a quiz show. Advertising Coordinator for Arts Hub Australia, Yuhan fancies himself a bit of a writer, singer and actor. One day he hopes to be able to dance as well.

E: yuhan@artshub.com.au

Related news

The Jinglists

The Jinglists

Matt D’Silva 4 Feb 2012

BONDI PAVILION: A quirky, slapstick comedy in the manner of Month Python, The Jinglists will make you laugh.

The Day The Sky Turned Black

The Day The Sky Turned Black

Chloe Papas 4 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Ali Kennedy-Scott's play chronicling the stories of everyday heroes who fought Victoria's ‘Black Saturday’ bushfires takes audiences on unrestrained emotional ride.

Three Strikes

Three Strikes

Astrid Francis 3 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: LA-based writer Brian Finkelstein weaves together tales of the US Writers' Strike of 2007 and Haymarket Massacre of 1886 into an ultimately gratifying whole.

On The Couch with the Freudian Dream Girls

On The Couch with the Freudian Dream Girls

Astrid Francis 3 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: If you want to have a dream interpreted in an unusual context, this is the show for you; if you are looking for something more theatrical, not so much.

The Magic Flute

The Magic Flute

Jennie Sharpe 4 Feb 2012

SYDNEY OPERA HOUSE: The Metropolitan Opera's The Magic Flute, reproduced by Opera Australia, does everything possible to bring it into the 21st century.

Cirque Appetit

Cirque Appetit

Angela Perry 1 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Cirque Appetit is a collective from Perth’s circus and theatre schools, who used comedy, performance art, circus, dance and physical theatre to delight the audience.

Barry Morgan’s World of Organs

Barry Morgan’s World of Organs

Mariyon Slany 31 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Good old-fashioned entertainment, Barry Morgan’s World of Organs is an innuendo-filled 1970s spoof on sales pitches, organs, bad polyester suits and organs.

Meow Meow

Meow Meow

Jessica Keath 31 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Meow Meow's sold-out festival closing night performance was a rare pleasure and a delight.

Cinderella

Cinderella

Patricia Maunder 30 Jan 2012

VICTORIAN OPERA: Outgoing musical director Richard Gill put on an unexpected yet entirely logical addition to his outstanding legacy with this all-too-short season of Cinderella.

West Side Story

West Side Story

Victor Kline 30 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: A presentation of the classic West Side Story with music performed live by the Sydney Symphony, this was a fun multi-media night fit to win over the cynics.

Bye Bye World

Bye Bye World

Astrid Francis 30 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Winner of last year's Best of Amsterdam Fringe, Bye Bye World is a beautifully crafted tale of the desire to reject one’s accumulated existence.

Thyestes

Thyestes

Marcus Costello 28 Jan 2012

COMPANY BELVOIR/CARRIAGEWORKS: A radical modernising of Seneca’s play, this production of Thyestes is harrowing but quite brilliant.

Zoo Twilight Series – James Morrison

Zoo Twilight Series – James Morrison

Suzanne Yanko 28 Jan 2012

MELBOURNE ZOO: The second in the Zoo’s 2012 Twilight Series had something for everyone, and left the mixed audience applauding and wishing there was more.

Ordinary Days

Ordinary Days

Gareth Beal 28 Jan 2012

DARLINGHURST THEATRE: A musical rom-com with an excellent cast, Ordinary Days boasts a strong narrative structure, but also leans towards sentimentality.

tUnE-yArDs

tUnE-yArDs

Leanne Minshull 28 Jan 2012

MONA FOMA: tUnE-yArDs delivered a great set as part of Tasmania's MONA FOMA festival, capping off an over-all extraordinary event.

Animagica

Animagica

Jessika Steiner 25 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Simple yet beautiful, Amiina's soundscapes created for film-maker Lotte Reiniger's shadow puppet fairytales take audiences on a journey of escapism.

Class Actress - Rapprocher

Class Actress - Rapprocher

Bernadette Burke 28 Jan 2012

EMI: Elizabeth Harper’s debut under the name Class Actress, Rapproacher is a catchy, fun party spinner perfectly suited to being pulled apart and remixed in a hundred different ways.

Proximity Micro Festival

Proximity Micro Festival

Astrid Francis 25 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: A program of small-scale theatre, dance and live-art, Proximity is for those who like the idea of being the performance, not just watching it.

In Vogue: Songs By Madonna

In Vogue: Songs By Madonna

Aleksia Barron 24 Jan 2012

MIDSUMMA: Michael Griffiths brings new meaning to Madonna's songs in a show that unites its audiences in joy.

PJ Harvey

PJ Harvey

Leanne Minshull 24 Jan 2012

MONA FOMA: Although PJ Harvey played a characteristally excellent set at PW1, the bane of short folk attending gigs everywhere - the backs of taller people's heads - detracted from the overall experience.