News, analysis and comment - performing arts 

MUSIC REVIEW: MIAF Philip Glass & Leonard Cohen

By ArtsHub ArtsHub | Thursday, October 16, 2008

  

The Philip Glass fan

I’m a big fan of Philip Glass and his exuberant minimalism and have been since I was a transfixed by his early opera ‘Einstein on the Beach’ as a young boy.

I loved this new work (it has been touring for about 18 months). But my companion, an avid fan of Leonard Cohen, hated every minute and we argued heatedly, (but shared a glass of wine), after the performance.

Glass remains at the height of conceptual and intellectual powers- his productivity is legendary- but he seems to be retreating from performance. Already looking weaker when he played, a little, during his Orion, performed here during the 2005 festival, Glass now has conductor/keyboardist Mick Rossi handle the florid, faster paced sections. Glass himself provides an iconic and slightly theatrical presence on the stage in this highly crafted, densely composed, choreographed and designed work that has been engineered in layers anticipating a diverse readership.

The Book of Longing is, at one level, an ambitious song cycle in the grand tradition of the genre. There are more than 20 of Cohen’s poems, some read by Cohen himself but most sung by a monophonic quartet – symmetrically gendered (Will Erat, Daniel Keeling, Dominque Plaisant, Tara Hugo) and set against the Glass’ densely textured instrumentations. At intervals, the principal string and woodwinds perform exquisite and lyrical solos.

If you are accustomed to Cohen, it takes a while to listen into Glass’ settings. The music seems at first distracting, the words hard to discern despite the emphatic monophony and single-part line set for the vocalists. The cycle develops as a great arch. The singers perform, and move to careful blocking, almost like stylized musical theatre. At intervals Cohen’s drawings and sketches, mostly from 2003/4 are projected on the scrim above the musicians. Cohen mostly draws women and himself.

But along the way something else becomes apparent. It is as if Glass has fused Cohen’s words – rich in their own assonances and textures, with his musical patterns- assimilating the complexity of Cohen’s language as another sound-layer in his music. The singers render the actual spoken words in strict monophony – as if to solve the perpetual issue in his music of finding clarity in complexity. This word-music co-texturing serves as a structural counterpoint to the intercalated solos, whose lyrical clarity is greatly augmented by the sharp contrast of their dense framing.

At the point of the last instrumental sole, on bowed double-base, Glass leaves the stage in the dark and returns, jacketed. He sits in chair and turns to face the solo, now sonorous –deeply beautiful – as image after image of Cohen is flashed on the scrim. It is subtle and obvious at the same time that we are to watch Glass watch himself and his work as we watch him.

Glass seems reflective. Sadly, (let’s hope very slowly) eternity nears. Will the future revere Glass as innovator and genius, the way we do Bartok and Shostakovich? And what has he really created here and in his now vast oeuvre?

Those questions are unresolved but Melbourne – some seeing Cohen afresh, some enjoying an operatic song cycle, some thinking they saw a little deeper- offered a standing ovation to a Master of our age.

Gary Anderson is a Melbourne academic

The Leonard Cohen fan

Okay I will be upfront – I am a Leonard Cohen fan from when I was a child – my family used to listen to all his albums, went to all his concerts, talked about his lyrics and poetry, and whether his work was truly gloomy or incredibly joyous – or possibly both at the same time…

For me Leonard Cohen is about a deep sonorous sound, and dense, sometimes indecipherable poetic verse and a sensual languid voice.

His music is rich, melodic, and intensely personal. For some I know – it’s not something to listen to when feeling a touch depressed (although for me Leonard Cohen’s music makes me happy!).

Now my expectations of this Philip Glass and Leonard Cohen union, was of something totally intriguing. To meld Cohen’s intimate poetry (and Cohen’s Book of Longing is a wonderfully personal work) with Glass’ most impressive technical skill as an eminent musician whose work is notoriously known to be anything but personal or intimate.

In a way this was potentially a Ying and Yang moment – where opposites could create a truly marvelous whole.

However I was not prepared to see Cohen’s poetry performed by the four singers who performed the song-cycle in what seemed to be a purposefully theatrical manner. Think Leonard Cohen meets Broadway.

Music Theatre is not a genre I had ever associated with Cohen and to tell the truth I found the singing incredibly jarring.

This quartet unrelentlessly sang Cohen’s 20 odd poems, moving studiedly across the stage, sitting, standing, drinking water, walking on and off. This was interwoven with recorded recitations by Cohen himself.

And this was probably the high point for me – hearing Cohen’s poetry read by Cohen with Philip Glass’ magnificent score and talented musicians playing.

Unfortunately these moments were too few for my liking and then I would be jarred out of my blissful moment with a quartet from monophonic hell.

Rita Dimasi is Arts Hub Executive Editor

Book of Longing
Philip Glass: music
Poetry and Images: Leonard Cohen
MIAF
State theatre Melbourne
15 October 2008

ArtsHub

To contact the ArtsHub news desk email editor@artshub.com.au. To get the latest media news to your desktop or mobile, follow ArtsHub on Twitter, Tumblr and Facebook.

E: editor@artshub.com.au

Related news

Morning of the Earth

Morning of the Earth

Tomas Boot 7 Feb 2012

SYDNEY OPERA HOUSE: This 40th anniversary screening of the iconic surf flick, accompanied by live music, proved that it's still as relevant today as it was back then.

Here, In the Sugarcane

Here, In the Sugarcane

Siobhan Argent 6 Feb 2012

STUDIO 246, BRUNSWICK: While showcasing the promising and consistent offerings at Studio 246, Here, In the Sugarcane could perhaps do with a tweak.

Doctor Who Symphonic Spectacular

Doctor Who Symphonic Spectacular

Patricia Maunder 6 Feb 2012

MELBOURNE SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA: This local version of the BBC's Doctor Who Proms is a treat for Doctor Who fans, but not as much for classical music fans.

Yes, Prime Minister

Yes, Prime Minister

Rebecca Butterworth 6 Feb 2012

COMEDY THEATRE, MELBOURNE: It was always going to be difficult to live up to the beloved TV shows, but Yes, Prime Minister the stage show is still entertaining.

The Burlesque Garden

The Burlesque Garden

Angela Perry 6 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: A tantalising mix of circus, music, dance, cabaret and burlesque combine in the Burlesque Garden.

The New Conway Explosion

The New Conway Explosion

Nerida Dickinson 6 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: John Conway demonstrates the power of madcap positivity to generate further antics in his high energy Fringe World comedy mishmash.

The Jinglists

The Jinglists

Matt D’Silva 4 Feb 2012

BONDI PAVILION: A quirky, slapstick comedy in the manner of Month Python, The Jinglists will make you laugh.

The Day The Sky Turned Black

The Day The Sky Turned Black

Chloe Papas 4 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Ali Kennedy-Scott's play chronicling the stories of everyday heroes who fought Victoria's ‘Black Saturday’ bushfires takes audiences on unrestrained emotional ride.

Three Strikes

Three Strikes

Astrid Francis 3 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: LA-based writer Brian Finkelstein weaves together tales of the US Writers' Strike of 2007 and Haymarket Massacre of 1886 into an ultimately gratifying whole.

On The Couch with the Freudian Dream Girls

On The Couch with the Freudian Dream Girls

Astrid Francis 3 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: If you want to have a dream interpreted in an unusual context, this is the show for you; if you are looking for something more theatrical, not so much.

The Magic Flute

The Magic Flute

Jennie Sharpe 4 Feb 2012

SYDNEY OPERA HOUSE: The Metropolitan Opera's The Magic Flute, reproduced by Opera Australia, does everything possible to bring it into the 21st century.

Cirque Appetit

Cirque Appetit

Angela Perry 1 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Cirque Appetit is a collective from Perth’s circus and theatre schools, who used comedy, performance art, circus, dance and physical theatre to delight the audience.

Barry Morgan’s World of Organs

Barry Morgan’s World of Organs

Mariyon Slany 31 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Good old-fashioned entertainment, Barry Morgan’s World of Organs is an innuendo-filled 1970s spoof on sales pitches, organs, bad polyester suits and organs.

Meow Meow

Meow Meow

Jessica Keath 31 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Meow Meow's sold-out festival closing night performance was a rare pleasure and a delight.

Cinderella

Cinderella

Patricia Maunder 30 Jan 2012

VICTORIAN OPERA: Outgoing musical director Richard Gill put on an unexpected yet entirely logical addition to his outstanding legacy with this all-too-short season of Cinderella.

West Side Story

West Side Story

Victor Kline 30 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: A presentation of the classic West Side Story with music performed live by the Sydney Symphony, this was a fun multi-media night fit to win over the cynics.

Bye Bye World

Bye Bye World

Astrid Francis 30 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Winner of last year's Best of Amsterdam Fringe, Bye Bye World is a beautifully crafted tale of the desire to reject one’s accumulated existence.

Thyestes

Thyestes

Marcus Costello 28 Jan 2012

COMPANY BELVOIR/CARRIAGEWORKS: A radical modernising of Seneca’s play, this production of Thyestes is harrowing but quite brilliant.

Zoo Twilight Series – James Morrison

Zoo Twilight Series – James Morrison

Suzanne Yanko 28 Jan 2012

MELBOURNE ZOO: The second in the Zoo’s 2012 Twilight Series had something for everyone, and left the mixed audience applauding and wishing there was more.

Ordinary Days

Ordinary Days

Gareth Beal 28 Jan 2012

DARLINGHURST THEATRE: A musical rom-com with an excellent cast, Ordinary Days boasts a strong narrative structure, but also leans towards sentimentality.