News, analysis and comment - film/tv/radio |
According to British filmmaker Peter Greenaway, the 1642 painting The Night Watch by Dutch artist Rembrandt Harmenszoon van Rijn is “an indictment … an accusation” – and contains a series of clues pointing to a murderous conspiracy, if only one knows where to look.
Greenaway’s claim that we don’t know how to look – that in the modern era we have become visually illiterate – is a key element of Rembrandt’s J’Accuse, a doco-drama which uses re-enactments and digital technology to explore the painting’s creation and composition; and to advance Greenaway’s twined arguments of murder and visual illiteracy.
Made as a companion piece to his 2007 film Nightwatching, a biopic about Rembrandt’s creation of The Night Watch, and re-using many of the former film’s dramatized scenes, J’Accuse is structured as a visual and auditory essay in which Greenaway advances his argument through a series of presentations exploring 31 of the 50 mysteries he believes the canvas contains.
According to Greenaway, after being commissioned to paint The Night Watch, a prestigious group portrait of a division of Amsterdam’s civic guards (thus the painting’s alternate title, the ‘Company of Frans Banning Cocq and Willem van Ruytenburch’), Rembrandt discovered that members of the regiment had murdered one of their peers and covered up the crime. Incensed at the musketeers’ culpability, Rembrandt subverted the traditional formal group portrait he was commissioned to paint into a damning accusation, concealing a series of clues within the painting pointing to the guilt of the men it portrays.
Ironically, the movie Greenaway has made to advance his argument about society’s visual literacy, and our reliance on the written word, is itself an overly wordy film. Greenaway himself appears in many of the film’s scenes, popping up to explain this point or that fact, and his verbose voice-over dominates the soundtrack; and his fractured vision and reliance on overlapping frames and multiple perspectives is initially engaging but becomes overused.
More damningly, many of the claims he makes about the painting go unsupported. No external references or commentators are presented to bolster or document Greenaway’s sweeping claims; and like crime writer Patricia Cornwell in her book Portrait of a Killer: Jack the Ripper – Case Closed, in his eagerness to mount a ‘definitive’ argument about The Night Watch, Greenaway ignores several facts which don’t fit his claims.
After The Night Watch was publically displayed, according to Greenaway, the influential men whose reputations Rembrandt had tarnished set out to destroy the painter in order to ensure their own careers did not suffer. But Rembrandt’s career did not suffer as a result of painting The Night Watch. In 1642, the artist received approximately 1,600 guilders for The Night Watch. Four years later the Prince of Orange gave him 2,400 guilders for two smaller works, so clearly Rembrandt was still successful 48 months after his alleged accusation on canvas went on show.
It’s true that Rembrandt’s career began to decline in later years, and by 1656 he was almost bankrupt, but the consensus among art historians such as Harvard’s Professor Seymour Slive is that it was the changing tastes of the Dutch public, coupled with the painter’s long-established extravagance, which resulted in his declining fortunes.
Nor was the painting itself poorly received after its unveiling. The Night Watch was originally hung in the Kloveniersdoelen, the headquarters of Amsterdam’s civic guards, thereafter being moved to a prominent location in the Amsterdam Town Hall – hardly the place you’d hide a damning accusation. Furthermore, Captain Banning Cocq – one of Greenaway’s alleged conspirators – had a personal copy of The Night Watch made for his own collection, which is scarcely the action of a man exposed as a murderer by the very same painting.
As leading Australian art critic Robert Nelson recently wrote in The Age:
‘Visual literacy consists not in inventing things that aren't there, but connecting the things that are. While reproaching the visually illiterate who only see what they want to see, Greenaway plunges into the very fallacy that he scorns.’
A dense, fascinating but deeply flawed film, Rembrandt’s J’Accuse is more intellectual curiosity than an important work; but if it encourages a deeper engagement with visual literacy, and a prolonged analysis of the works of the old masters, it is nonetheless to be welcomed as an interesting addition to the canon of the Western cinema tradition which Greenaway himself scorns as “impoverished”.
Rembrandt’s J’Accuse
Directed by Peter Greenaway
Produced by Bruno Felix and Femke Wolting
Cinematography by Reinier van Brummelen
Stars Martin Freeman, Eva Birthistle, Jonathan Holmes, Michael Teigen and Peter Greenaway
Melbourne International Arts Festival
October 9 – 24, 2009
Richard Watts is a Melbourne-based arts writer and broadcaster. In addition to writing for Arts Hub he presents the weekly program SmartArts on 3RRR. Richard has worked for a wide array of arts organisations, and has sat on numerous boards. Follow him on Twitter: @richardthewatts
E: editor@artshub.com.auSarah Ward 21 May 2012
ICON: This subtle Russian drama is a poetic, poignant meditation on mortality, finality and farewells.
Leo Ribeiro 18 May 2012
MADMAN: This is not a film is an elegantly defiant must-see video diary from censored Iranian filmmaker Jafar Panahi, now avaliable on DVD.
Beth Anderson 18 May 2012
ICON HOME ENTERTAINMENT: Stephan Elliot’s latest film goes beyond slapstick and farce to the dangerous territory of slapdash; it’s forced, unfunny and painfully exaggerated.
Sarah Ward 18 May 2012
ROADSHOW: Hammer Films return to their gothic format of old with this eerie tale of ghosts and grief starring Daniel Radcliffe.
Susanna Nelson 16 May 2012
MADMAN DVD: The latest film from auteur Lars von Trier is a fluent essay on the human mind – what frees it, what troubles it, what paralyses it.
Sarah Ward 16 May 2012
HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS & FILM FESTIVAL: A compelling documentary exploring the lives of young Thais who work as Muay Thai fighters on the controversial children’s circuit.
Sarah Ward 16 May 2012
HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS & FILM FESTIVAL: The winner of two Goya Awards, this gentle gem of a film is a carefully considered depiction of one man’s struggle with Alzheimer’s.
Paul Mitchell 15 May 2012
MADMAN: Through the story of one man’s remarkable passion for creativity, this riveting documentary gets to the heart of fashion’s place in the human story.
Sarah Ward 14 May 2012
HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS AND FILM FESTIVAL: Documentarian Joe Berlinger examines the furore around Paul Simon's album ‘Graceland’, recorded in South Africa at the height of apartheid.
Sarah Ward 14 May 2012
ANTIDOTE FILMS: Though not up to the standard of his best work, the latest film from Australian director John Duigan illustrates his penchant for finding poignancy in difficult topics.
Liza Dezfouli 14 May 2012
MADMAN: An interconnected trilogy of tales, Giovanni Veronisi’s romantic drama was the smash hit of the 2011 Lavazza Italian Film Festival.
Sarah Ward 11 May 2012
SECOND NATURE FILMS: This distinctly one-sided documentary examines the popularity of yoga – formerly a male discipline – amongst women worldwide.
Beth Anderson 11 May 2012
ABC DVD/ROADSHOW: In space, no-one can hear you squeal. A six-part comedy series about a gay science fiction fan club and the lives, loves, and never-ending dramas of its five members.
Lee Zachariah 11 May 2012
ICON: A bold trio of films about love and loss from acclaimed director Krzysztof Kieslowski, now available as a DVD box set.
Sarah Ward 9 May 2012
ROADSHOW: In his latest film, a remake of a cult US TV series from the 1960’s, director Tim Burton is once again painting by numbers.
Nicole Eckersley 9 May 2012
MADMAN DVD: A behind-the-scenes look into the kitchen of three Michelin-starred chef Ferran Adrià, widely considered the best, most innovative and craziest chef in the world.
Elspeth McIntosh 8 May 2012
MADMAN: A gripping, political thriller that examines the origins of the Middle East conflict in events that took place under British rule 60 years ago.
Sarah Ward 8 May 2012
MADMAN: The latest film from eclectic director Michael Winterbottom is a contemporary update of a Thomas Hardy novel, set in India.
Sarah Ward 8 May 2012
CURIOUS FILMS: A documentary about the world’s greatest sushi chef hardly sounds like compelling viewing, but that’s exactly what this film is; a cinematic, gastronomic treat.
Leon Marvell 4 May 2012
MADMAN: This five-part documentary series, now available on DVD, is a somewhat rushed guide to the film industries of China, Taiwan, South Korea, India and Iran.