News, analysis and comment - film/tv/radio |
TO DIE LIKE A MAN
The latest film from Portuguese director João Pedro Rodrigues is, like his earlier works O Fantasma (2000) and Odete, a queer-themed drama that borders on melodrama; but unlike his first two films, To Die Like a Man is filmed in such a stylised and fragmented way as to drain almost all emotion from the story in progress.
The film opens with a group of camouflage-clad soldiers on a night-time training exercise in a forest. Two of the men creep away from their comrades, and once alone, fall into a passionate embrace which leads quickly to sex, and then to murder.
Next we meet Tonia (Fernando Santos), an aging drag queen dealing simultaneously with two major dramas: his loss of status in the nightclub where he has worked for years, and a highly strung junkie boyfriend, Rosario (Alexander David), who is young enough to be his own son.
At Rosario’s insistence, Tonia is contemplating having a full sex change; a procedure which is explained to viewers in detail early in the film through the inventive use of origami, but we are given no indication that gender reassignment would bring any form of stability to the pair’s relationship, even once Rosario gives up using heroin. Instead we explore the petty details day-to-day of Tonia’s life: her falling out with an old friend, her fights with an up-and-coming young drag queen at work, and her infected, pus-leaking left nipple.
Just when it seems we are going to be witnessing a mundane domestic drama (well, as mundane as any drama can be whose main character is a highly strung drag queen), the film takes a twist by reintroducing the murderous young soldier we met in the first scene. He is, of course, Tonia’s son.
Before we have even had a chance to process this revelation, the film swiftly enters road trip territory – and very trippy territory it is, with Tonia and Rosario encountering a reclusive transsexual couple living in the forest who take them snipe hunting (despite the fact that snipe are extinct). It’s at this point that things get seriously fragmentary, with a sepia-toned musical sequence by an Antony and the Johnsons sound-alike sweeping up the characters for several excruciating minutes, after which we’re back to the action, and indeed, back to melodrama.
Of all the films I have seen at MIFF to date, To Die Like a Man is the most baffling and frustrating. Like a deranged cross between Fassbinder and Almodovar, Rodrigues introduces plot elements only to discard them minutes later; embraces melodrama only to abandon it in favour of formal abstraction; and coaxes both magnificent and scenery-chewing performances from his cast.
There is a heartfelt and poignant drama buried somewhere in To Die Like a Man, but unfortunately it is lost – no doubt deliberately – amidst the fragmented, arch and dry film that Rodrigues has crafted.
To Die Like a Man (dir. João Pedro Rodrigues from his own screenplay, produced by Maria Joao Sigalho, Portugal/France 2009)
Melbourne International Film Festival, June 22 – August 8
’It’s a matter of taste’
Richard Watts is a Melbourne-based arts writer and broadcaster. In addition to writing for Arts Hub he presents the weekly program SmartArts on 3RRR. Richard has worked for a wide array of arts organisations, and has sat on numerous boards. Follow him on Twitter: @richardthewatts
E: editor@artshub.com.auSarah Ward 21 May 2012
ICON: This subtle Russian drama is a poetic, poignant meditation on mortality, finality and farewells.
Leo Ribeiro 18 May 2012
MADMAN: This is not a film is an elegantly defiant must-see video diary from censored Iranian filmmaker Jafar Panahi, now avaliable on DVD.
Beth Anderson 18 May 2012
ICON HOME ENTERTAINMENT: Stephan Elliot’s latest film goes beyond slapstick and farce to the dangerous territory of slapdash; it’s forced, unfunny and painfully exaggerated.
Sarah Ward 18 May 2012
ROADSHOW: Hammer Films return to their gothic format of old with this eerie tale of ghosts and grief starring Daniel Radcliffe.
Susanna Nelson 16 May 2012
MADMAN DVD: The latest film from auteur Lars von Trier is a fluent essay on the human mind – what frees it, what troubles it, what paralyses it.
Sarah Ward 16 May 2012
HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS & FILM FESTIVAL: A compelling documentary exploring the lives of young Thais who work as Muay Thai fighters on the controversial children’s circuit.
Sarah Ward 16 May 2012
HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS & FILM FESTIVAL: The winner of two Goya Awards, this gentle gem of a film is a carefully considered depiction of one man’s struggle with Alzheimer’s.
Paul Mitchell 15 May 2012
MADMAN: Through the story of one man’s remarkable passion for creativity, this riveting documentary gets to the heart of fashion’s place in the human story.
Sarah Ward 14 May 2012
HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS AND FILM FESTIVAL: Documentarian Joe Berlinger examines the furore around Paul Simon's album ‘Graceland’, recorded in South Africa at the height of apartheid.
Sarah Ward 14 May 2012
ANTIDOTE FILMS: Though not up to the standard of his best work, the latest film from Australian director John Duigan illustrates his penchant for finding poignancy in difficult topics.
Liza Dezfouli 14 May 2012
MADMAN: An interconnected trilogy of tales, Giovanni Veronisi’s romantic drama was the smash hit of the 2011 Lavazza Italian Film Festival.
Sarah Ward 11 May 2012
SECOND NATURE FILMS: This distinctly one-sided documentary examines the popularity of yoga – formerly a male discipline – amongst women worldwide.
Beth Anderson 11 May 2012
ABC DVD/ROADSHOW: In space, no-one can hear you squeal. A six-part comedy series about a gay science fiction fan club and the lives, loves, and never-ending dramas of its five members.
Lee Zachariah 11 May 2012
ICON: A bold trio of films about love and loss from acclaimed director Krzysztof Kieslowski, now available as a DVD box set.
Sarah Ward 9 May 2012
ROADSHOW: In his latest film, a remake of a cult US TV series from the 1960’s, director Tim Burton is once again painting by numbers.
Nicole Eckersley 9 May 2012
MADMAN DVD: A behind-the-scenes look into the kitchen of three Michelin-starred chef Ferran Adrià, widely considered the best, most innovative and craziest chef in the world.
Elspeth McIntosh 8 May 2012
MADMAN: A gripping, political thriller that examines the origins of the Middle East conflict in events that took place under British rule 60 years ago.
Sarah Ward 8 May 2012
MADMAN: The latest film from eclectic director Michael Winterbottom is a contemporary update of a Thomas Hardy novel, set in India.
Sarah Ward 8 May 2012
CURIOUS FILMS: A documentary about the world’s greatest sushi chef hardly sounds like compelling viewing, but that’s exactly what this film is; a cinematic, gastronomic treat.
Leon Marvell 4 May 2012
MADMAN: This five-part documentary series, now available on DVD, is a somewhat rushed guide to the film industries of China, Taiwan, South Korea, India and Iran.