News, analysis and comment - film/tv/radio 

Elite Squad: The Enemy Within

By Sarah Ward artsHub | Wednesday, February 22, 2012

  

In 2007, semi-fictional Brazilian film The Elite Squad brought the story of Rio de Janeiro’s special operations battalion within the city’s military police to the screen. After succeeding beyond expectations, including winning the Golden Bear at the 2008 Berlin Film Festival and garnering a cult following, a second instalment became inevitable. Three years later a sequel emerged, exploring the intersection of law enforcement and politics. Quickly ranking as the highest grossing movie of all time in its homeland, that feature is Elite Squad: The Enemy Within (Tropa de Elite 2 – O Inimigo Agora é Outro).

Set 13 years after the first effort, the continuation commences with a prison riot. The fallout from the fight – dubbed a human rights massacre by the media – ensnares unit captain Roberto Nascimento (Wagner Moura, Romance), with the blame for the death of an inmate falling at his feet. The man responsible for the surge against him is his son’s stepfather Diogo Fraga (Irandhir Santos, Bog of Beasts), a politician with the ear of the Governor crusading for the rights of prisoners. Moved to internal security as a promotion in lieu of punishment, Nascimento attempts to fight the system – and combat the mounting carnage – from the inside.

With Nascimento’s narration guiding the film, writer/director José Padilha’s return to the topics of political instability and police corruption is grounded in the experience of the protagonist on a personal and professional level. As a result, viewers unfamiliar with the first offering are eased into the action, with knowledge of prior events beneficial but far from essential.

Seething with anger at the dishonesty depicted, the feature is an explosive, energetic effort. Reminiscent of co-scribe Bráulio Mantovani’s City of God – albeit from the police rather than slum inhabitants’ perspective – it is frenetic and furious in its presentation of the city’s senseless slaughter. As the film’s dissection of the improbity of public office deepens, it also recalls acclaimed television series The Wire. Merging the vitality of the former and astuteness of the latter, it paints a powerful portrait of the duplicity of modern South America.

Featuring effective performances from the male-centric cast, including a fiery turn from returning star Moura, Elite Squad: The Enemy Within offers an immersive amalgamation of explicit intensity, conflicted characters and a necessarily gritty aesthetic. Although unable to perfect the balance between thrills and commentary, it entertains and engages, making for pulsating and potent viewing.

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

Elite Squad: The Enemy Within
Director: José Padilha
Brazil, 2010, 115 min

Out now on DVD
Distributor: Madman
Rated MA

Sarah Ward

Sarah Ward is a Brisbane-based freelance film critic, writer and festival devotee. In addition to writing for a range of cinema, culture and festival websites, she has worked for a number of entertainment and arts organisations, including her current role at the Brisbane International Film Festival. Follow her on Twitter: @swardplay

E: editor@artshub.com.au

Related news

This American Life - Live

This American Life - Live

Melanie Burge 23 May 2012

SHARMILL FILMS: Hosted by Ira Glass, a live concert version of this much-loved public radio program is about to screen in selected Australian cinemas.

Silent Souls

Silent Souls

Sarah Ward 21 May 2012

ICON: This subtle Russian drama is a poetic, poignant meditation on mortality, finality and farewells.

This is not a film

This is not a film

Leo Ribeiro 18 May 2012

MADMAN: This is not a film is an elegantly defiant must-see video diary from censored Iranian filmmaker Jafar Panahi, now avaliable on DVD.

A Few Best Men

A Few Best Men

Beth Anderson 18 May 2012

ICON HOME ENTERTAINMENT: Stephan Elliot’s latest film goes beyond slapstick and farce to the dangerous territory of slapdash; it’s forced, unfunny and painfully exaggerated.

The Woman in Black

The Woman in Black

Sarah Ward 18 May 2012

ROADSHOW: Hammer Films return to their gothic format of old with this eerie tale of ghosts and grief starring Daniel Radcliffe.

Melancholia

Melancholia

Susanna Nelson 16 May 2012

MADMAN DVD: The latest film from auteur Lars von Trier is a fluent essay on the human mind – what frees it, what troubles it, what paralyses it.

Buffalo Girls

Buffalo Girls

Sarah Ward 16 May 2012

HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS & FILM FESTIVAL: A compelling documentary exploring the lives of young Thais who work as Muay Thai fighters on the controversial children’s circuit.

Wrinkles

Wrinkles

Sarah Ward 16 May 2012

HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS & FILM FESTIVAL: The winner of two Goya Awards, this gentle gem of a film is a carefully considered depiction of one man’s struggle with Alzheimer’s.

Bill Cunningham New York

Bill Cunningham New York

Paul Mitchell 15 May 2012

MADMAN: Through the story of one man’s remarkable passion for creativity, this riveting documentary gets to the heart of fashion’s place in the human story.

Under African Skies

Under African Skies

Sarah Ward 14 May 2012

HUMAN RIGHTS ARTS AND FILM FESTIVAL: Documentarian Joe Berlinger examines the furore around Paul Simon's album ‘Graceland’, recorded in South Africa at the height of apartheid.

Careless Love

Careless Love

Sarah Ward 14 May 2012

ANTIDOTE FILMS: Though not up to the standard of his best work, the latest film from Australian director John Duigan illustrates his penchant for finding poignancy in difficult topics.

Ages of Love

Ages of Love

Liza Dezfouli 14 May 2012

MADMAN: An interconnected trilogy of tales, Giovanni Veronisi’s romantic drama was the smash hit of the 2011 Lavazza Italian Film Festival.

Yogawoman

Yogawoman

Sarah Ward 11 May 2012

SECOND NATURE FILMS: This distinctly one-sided documentary examines the popularity of yoga – formerly a male discipline – amongst women worldwide.

Outland

Outland

Beth Anderson 11 May 2012

ABC DVD/ROADSHOW: In space, no-one can hear you squeal. A six-part comedy series about a gay science fiction fan club and the lives, loves, and never-ending dramas of its five members.

Three Colours Trilogy

Three Colours Trilogy

Lee Zachariah 11 May 2012

ICON: A bold trio of films about love and loss from acclaimed director Krzysztof Kieslowski, now available as a DVD box set.

Dark Shadows

Dark Shadows

Sarah Ward 9 May 2012

ROADSHOW: In his latest film, a remake of a cult US TV series from the 1960’s, director Tim Burton is once again painting by numbers.

El Bulli: Cooking in Progress

El Bulli: Cooking in Progress

Nicole Eckersley 9 May 2012

MADMAN DVD: A behind-the-scenes look into the kitchen of three Michelin-starred chef Ferran Adrià, widely considered the best, most innovative and craziest chef in the world.

The Promise

The Promise

Elspeth McIntosh 8 May 2012

MADMAN: A gripping, political thriller that examines the origins of the Middle East conflict in events that took place under British rule 60 years ago.

Trishna

Trishna

Sarah Ward 8 May 2012

MADMAN: The latest film from eclectic director Michael Winterbottom is a contemporary update of a Thomas Hardy novel, set in India.

Jiro Dreams of Sushi

Jiro Dreams of Sushi

Sarah Ward 8 May 2012

CURIOUS FILMS: A documentary about the world’s greatest sushi chef hardly sounds like compelling viewing, but that’s exactly what this film is; a cinematic, gastronomic treat.