News, analysis and comment - performing arts 

SIGNAL TO NOISE

The Devil’s Tools

By Paul Callaghan ArtsHub | Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Censorship is an ever-present hot-button topic, and in the past 12 months the debate has become increasingly visible - from the situation around Bill Henson’s work to Labour’s proposed Internet filter, a huge amount of media space has been devoted to the issues around censorship, classification, and what constitutes inappropriate material.

And video games, despite their lack of mainstream media attention, have not escaped unscathed.

Video games are subject to the same classification process as films. In order to be distributed in Australia, they must be submitted to the Office of Film and Literature where they’re assigned a classification ranging from E – suitable for everyone - through PG – parental guidance – to MA15+. Unlike films, that’s where games stop. Any game that contains content beyond that, including high impact violence or sexual content that would be lead to an R18+ in a film is refused classification and cannot legally be sold in Australia. (As an aside, Australia is the only western country without an 18+ classification for video games.)

Arguments for and against this situation exist, and are argued across the Internet, but the system can only be changed by agreement by all state Attorney Generals, and last year, a draft paper was tabled which should have led to public consultation and hopefully to the introduction of an R18+ rating for games, bringing them in line with films.

However, the SA Attorney General, Michael Atkinson, has consistently blocked introduction of any changes to the rating system, citing concerns around violent games and their impact on children, saying “the repeated act of killing a computer-generated person or creature desensitises children to violence. It makes violence part of their everyday lives and what is especially concerning is that it is their re-creation. A child being able to watch sex and violence in a movie is damaging to the child, but the child participating in sex and violence in a computer game is worse.”

This has led, which shouldn’t be unexpected given the vocal nature of the games playing community, to a vociferous outpouring of anger against Mr Atkinson, both online and in letters and emails sent to his office.

The issue of censorship and classification is a difficult one, and studies into the real world effects of video games have largely been contradictory or inconclusive, but what does all of this mean for the people actually making the games and living inside the creative and commercial realities of the system?

The short answer is not much really.

Market-wise, Australia is a fraction the size of those in US, Europe, or Japan. Developers creating games here are, through the sheer force of numbers, focused on those areas and there is little to no incentive, other than cultural connection, in creating a game solely for the Australian market. The vast majority of the over 2000 developers in Australia are working on work-for-hire projects, creating games based on existing properties, owned by overseas companies, as tie-ins for movies or comics, and not creating original works. The risks involved in creating an R18+ rated game, and the ensuing reduction in market size, simply isn’t worth betting the farm on, and this is a fact borne out historically. If you look at the range of titles released by Australian developers, out of around 50 games developed here over the years, only one or two even come close to containing content that would nudge the R18+ rating.

So, you might say, what about independent titles - those games that are more about creatively pushing the boundaries of the medium, produced by an individual or a small team with a clearly defined aesthetic perspective? Well, it’s even less relevant for them because they’ll just avoid the OFLC all together and distribute their games on the Internet, perhaps for free, and likely finding an audience much larger than just Australia.

The reality of all of this is that censorship and classification is an inevitable part of the development of every art form. That’s not to condone it – I absolutely believe that adults should be able to create and play the games that they want – but every new medium, from novels to rock music to films to comics, is blamed for the downfall of society and is subject to some level of scrutiny and censorship, either by the industry producing it or by the government. Eventually though, people who grew up with these mediums find their way into positions of power, realise that the world didn’t fall completely apart, and turn the prongs of their pitchforks and the light of their torches onto something new. This has all happened before, and will happen again, with history showing that the only way to win is to keep creating work and cultivating patience.

And if, by chance, that doesn’t work, then there’s always an audience waiting on the other side of the world.

Paul Callaghan

Paul Callaghan is a Melbourne based freelance writer and game developer.

E: editor@artshub.com.au

Related news

The Jinglists

The Jinglists

Matt D’Silva 4 Feb 2012

BONDI PAVILION: A quirky, slapstick comedy in the manner of Month Python, The Jinglists will make you laugh.

The Day The Sky Turned Black

The Day The Sky Turned Black

Chloe Papas 4 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Ali Kennedy-Scott's play chronicling the stories of everyday heroes who fought Victoria's ‘Black Saturday’ bushfires takes audiences on unrestrained emotional ride.

Three Strikes

Three Strikes

Astrid Francis 3 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: LA-based writer Brian Finkelstein weaves together tales of the US Writers' Strike of 2007 and Haymarket Massacre of 1886 into an ultimately gratifying whole.

On The Couch with the Freudian Dream Girls

On The Couch with the Freudian Dream Girls

Astrid Francis 3 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: If you want to have a dream interpreted in an unusual context, this is the show for you; if you are looking for something more theatrical, not so much.

The Magic Flute

The Magic Flute

Jennie Sharpe 4 Feb 2012

SYDNEY OPERA HOUSE: The Metropolitan Opera's The Magic Flute, reproduced by Opera Australia, does everything possible to bring it into the 21st century.

Cirque Appetit

Cirque Appetit

Angela Perry 1 Feb 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Cirque Appetit is a collective from Perth’s circus and theatre schools, who used comedy, performance art, circus, dance and physical theatre to delight the audience.

Barry Morgan’s World of Organs

Barry Morgan’s World of Organs

Mariyon Slany 31 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Good old-fashioned entertainment, Barry Morgan’s World of Organs is an innuendo-filled 1970s spoof on sales pitches, organs, bad polyester suits and organs.

Meow Meow

Meow Meow

Jessica Keath 31 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Meow Meow's sold-out festival closing night performance was a rare pleasure and a delight.

Cinderella

Cinderella

Patricia Maunder 30 Jan 2012

VICTORIAN OPERA: Outgoing musical director Richard Gill put on an unexpected yet entirely logical addition to his outstanding legacy with this all-too-short season of Cinderella.

West Side Story

West Side Story

Victor Kline 30 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: A presentation of the classic West Side Story with music performed live by the Sydney Symphony, this was a fun multi-media night fit to win over the cynics.

Bye Bye World

Bye Bye World

Astrid Francis 30 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: Winner of last year's Best of Amsterdam Fringe, Bye Bye World is a beautifully crafted tale of the desire to reject one’s accumulated existence.

Thyestes

Thyestes

Marcus Costello 28 Jan 2012

COMPANY BELVOIR/CARRIAGEWORKS: A radical modernising of Seneca’s play, this production of Thyestes is harrowing but quite brilliant.

Zoo Twilight Series – James Morrison

Zoo Twilight Series – James Morrison

Suzanne Yanko 28 Jan 2012

MELBOURNE ZOO: The second in the Zoo’s 2012 Twilight Series had something for everyone, and left the mixed audience applauding and wishing there was more.

Ordinary Days

Ordinary Days

Gareth Beal 28 Jan 2012

DARLINGHURST THEATRE: A musical rom-com with an excellent cast, Ordinary Days boasts a strong narrative structure, but also leans towards sentimentality.

tUnE-yArDs

tUnE-yArDs

Leanne Minshull 28 Jan 2012

MONA FOMA: tUnE-yArDs delivered a great set as part of Tasmania's MONA FOMA festival, capping off an over-all extraordinary event.

Audience Development

Audience Development

Callum Moncrieff 25 Jan 2012

MUSIC: In line with a very familiar tree-related philosophy, does art exist if there is no one around to see or hear it?

Animagica

Animagica

Jessika Steiner 25 Jan 2012

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Simple yet beautiful, Amiina's soundscapes created for film-maker Lotte Reiniger's shadow puppet fairytales take audiences on a journey of escapism.

Class Actress - Rapprocher

Class Actress - Rapprocher

Bernadette Burke 28 Jan 2012

EMI: Elizabeth Harper’s debut under the name Class Actress, Rapproacher is a catchy, fun party spinner perfectly suited to being pulled apart and remixed in a hundred different ways.

Proximity Micro Festival

Proximity Micro Festival

Astrid Francis 25 Jan 2012

FRINGE WORLD: A program of small-scale theatre, dance and live-art, Proximity is for those who like the idea of being the performance, not just watching it.

In Vogue: Songs By Madonna

In Vogue: Songs By Madonna

Aleksia Barron 24 Jan 2012

MIDSUMMA: Michael Griffiths brings new meaning to Madonna's songs in a show that unites its audiences in joy.