News, analysis and comment - arts 

Simply ‘Chick Lit’? Forget it.

By Sarah Adams artsHub | Tuesday, February 07, 2012

Photo from flickr user: Rachel Sian  

Excitement is mounting surrounding a unique initiative that aims to curb the gender bias in the literary world. Literary sexism, it appears, is alive and well and the Australian Women Writers 2012 Reading and Reviewing Challenge is working to help swing some of the literary love in the direction of the fairer sex.

Finding the solution to gender bias in the literature world is firstly about figuring out the cause. After all, it seems that literature is a women’s world. Literature tutes at universities unequivocally contain a majority of females and, according to British research, women buy almost twice as many books of all kinds as men. Men undertaking arts degrees are shooting fish in a barrel if they are looking for love.

Women also write approximately half the books published, so there is no disparity content-wise. The publishing industry is also dominated by dames, with women taking up 62 per cent of publishing roles (although most senior roles are held by men). In the US, Britain and Germany, 80% of fiction readers are women. Author Ian McEwan said, ‘when women stop reading, the novel will be dead.’

Yet women are notoriously underrepresented when it comes to book reviews. VIDA, an American women’s literary organisation, surveyed some of the leading literary and cultural journals in the United Kingdom and United States, measuring up the number of books reviews written by males and females and the number of male and female authors that received reviews.

The results are heavily skewed in the male favour, and these are high quality publications such as The New York Times Book Review and the London Review of Books, to the point where the slice of the pie taken up by females is as measly as a single trivial pursuit victory. In The New York Times Book Review for example, nearly two books by men were reviewed for every one by a woman.

Crime writer Tara Moss writes on her blog of the VIDA survey: “Reading those statistics was a shock to me, as they would be to anyone else... The point is, the bias is unconscious, which means most of us are unaware of it. When we are made aware of it, it is surprising indeed. Like many book lovers and reviewers, it made me look at my own reading lists and reviews to see if I, too, was letting that unconscious bias creep in.”

Blogger Elizabeth Lhuede was inspired to start the Australian Women Writers 2012 Reading and Reviewing Challenge after reading Moss’s comments and looking at the statistics. Lhuede says that after reading the crime queen’s comments, “I realised then how often in discussions on gender bias, men were blamed for the problem of the lack of reviews, even though women constitute the bulk of readers (and roles in publishing and bookselling).”

“I knew I hadn't been doing much reading (except of books by friends), let alone reviewing. It occurred to me to wonder if women were handing their power over to men, being victims, instead of doing something positive to change things. Instead of waiting and hoping male readers might change, couldn't women make a conscious effort to read and review more books by other Australian women? That's really what inspired me to create the challenge, the desire to make a difference,” she explains.

With her challenge, women are doing just that. In January of this year 229 people had already signed on to read and review books by Australian women during 2012, in all genres. Already more than 76 books by Australian women have been posted on the challenge page since January 1st, and it’s only just beginning. It is hoped that increasing the reviews and notoriety of novels penned by women may also help correct inequity when it comes to major prizes and awards as well.

The Miles Franklin Award is one that has drawn some of the most attention for lack of female representation. This is especially significant considering that the awards’ namesake, Stella Miles Franklin, was one of Australia’s most prolific early Australian fiction writers. Her novel My Brilliant Careeer is one of the most revered in our small but steadfast literary history.

Despite the awards being named after a female writer, a woman has won only 13 times in its more than 50 year history and four of these times this was Thea Astley, who twice shared the award. In the past decade only two women have won, inspiring a female only offshoot of the awards, the ‘Stella’ awards, which work in much the same way as Britain's Orange Prize for fiction. Lhuede hopes to raise the profile of the Stella prize through her work as well.

Lhuede has asked Australian women readers: “How many books by Australian women do you read and review? The answer for many women I've contacted (including myself until the last sixth months) is "surprisingly few".”

“I want the challenge to help change that. I've discovered some very talented writers since I've consciously focused on reading books by Australian women - and I don't mean the older generation of Elizabeth Jolley and Thea Astley, or the well-known ones like Kate Grenville, Geraldine Brooks and Helen Garner. I mean younger authors including Gail Jones, Heather Rose, Charlotte Wood, Kalinda Ashton and Kirsten Tranter - all talented writers.”

For the moment, bookshops, teachers, librarians and readers from all corners of Australia are getting involved via Twitter (#aww2012 hashtag), blogs and Facebook. The challenge is a perfect fit for National Year of Reading activities already taking place in 2012.

If you want to get involved visit http://www.australianwomenwriters.com/p/australian-women-writers-book-challenge_25.html

Sarah Adams

Sarah Adams is a writer and sub-editor for ArtsHub. Follow her on twitter @sezadams

E: editor@artshub.com.au

Related news

Rebecca Harkins-Cross

Rebecca Harkins-Cross

artsHub 23 May 2012

Rebecca Harkins-Cross took over as the Project Coordinator of The Under Age in February this year.

Fluoro mag named Gold Winner at Summit Awards

Fluoro mag named Gold Winner at Summit Awards

artsHub 23 May 2012

The ninth issue of fluoro magazine, imaginatively named fluoro9, has taken out the Gold Award at the prestigious Summit International Awards in the US.

Artists tackle sport in Basil Sellers Art Prize

Artists tackle sport in Basil Sellers Art Prize

artsHub 23 May 2012

There’s really no reason that the arts and sports must remain the most bitter of rivals.

agIdeas live blog, 23 May (Part 2)

agIdeas live blog, 23 May (Part 2)

Freya Davies 23 May 2012

It's post lunch, and our woman on the ground Freya Davies is keeping us abreast of all things design with our agIdeas live blog.

ASA concerned over budget cuts to TAFE

ASA concerned over budget cuts to TAFE

artsHub 23 May 2012

Last week’s Victorian budget caused major concern among the TAFE community, with staff cuts and resources slashed from libraries.

will.i.am joins Vivid Sydney 2012

will.i.am joins Vivid Sydney 2012

artsHub 23 May 2012

Deputy Premier Andrew Stoner this week announced that musician and creative maestro will.i.am will take his place alongside an astronomical line-up of international artists, musicians and thought leaders for Vivid Sydney 2012.

agIdeas live blog, 23 May

agIdeas live blog, 23 May

Freya Davies 23 May 2012

Follow our live blog of the agIdeas design conference. Freya Davies gives us the low down on proceedings on Wednesday 23rd May.

Writers without borders

Writers without borders

Matt Millikan 22 May 2012

In her last year as Director of the Emerging Writers' Festival, Lisa Dempster leaves a legacy of breaking the boundaries of the written word.

Controversy over $20,000 grant for metal band

Controversy over $20,000 grant for metal band

artsHub 22 May 2012

3AW shock-jock has questioned the artistic merit of death metal, after band OUROBOROS received $20,000 from the Australia Council to record their new album.

Screen Australia funds new documentaries

Screen Australia funds new documentaries

artsHub 22 May 2012

Seven documentaries have shared $1.8m in investments from Screen Australia, including the four-part documentary series 'Once upon a time in Punchbowl'.

Spotify launches in Australia

Spotify launches in Australia

artsHub 22 May 2012

American users have been enjoying Spotify for a while now, but now – and with much bravado – the highly anticipated digital music service has launched in Australia.

Australians are supporting their film industry

Australians are supporting their film industry

artsHub 22 May 2012

Research compiled by the Australian Video Rental Retailers Assocation (AVRRA) has shown that 2.5 million Australians have been exposed to just a small selection of films born and bred in the Australian film industry thanks to ...

Anna Lumb

Anna Lumb

artsHub 22 May 2012

Anna Lumb (AKA Anna The Pocket Rocket) is an international artist specialising in circus, theatre and comedy.

Maude Davey

Maude Davey

artsHub 22 May 2012

Maude Davey is a writer, director, singer and actor, renowned for her nail gun monologues and charming, disarming, iconoclastic, political diatribes.

Lindy Hume is the new Chair for Regional Arts NSW

Lindy Hume is the new Chair for Regional Arts NSW

artsHub 24 May 2012

Regional Arts NSW has a new chair on the board. Lindy Hume takes the place of Meg Larkin who has retired.

Country Art Escapes Art Trail in North-West NSW

Country Art Escapes Art Trail in North-West NSW

artsHub 24 May 2012

The New England North West Regional Art Trail is now AKA Country Art Escapes but its purpose is unchanged, to promote cultural tourism in the region.

Visual arts winners in the Central West at Cowra

Visual arts winners in the Central West at Cowra

artsHub 24 May 2012

Canberra-based artist G. W. Bot has won the 2012 Calleen Art Award and Hill End artist Genevieve Carroll took out the Central West Regional Artists Award for 2012.

Sydney Film Festival's Official Competition films

Sydney Film Festival's Official Competition films

artsHub 22 May 2012

What would a film festival be without some friendly competition? The Sydney Film Festival has announced the 12 lucky films set to compete for the Sydney Film Prize this June.

Blackfella Films @ Sydney Film Festival

Blackfella Films @ Sydney Film Festival

artsHub 22 May 2012

In a partnership to rival all others, the Sydney Film Festival is collaborating with Blackfella Films to provide the best Indigenous films from Australia and around the world to the festival audience.

Sydney Film Festival presents the new Festival Hub

Sydney Film Festival presents the new Festival Hub

artsHub 22 May 2012

The Sydney Film Festival’s Festival Hub offers a special ‘insiders’ view into the festival, presenting an array of exciting events for all film fans.