News, analysis and comment

APRA's response to Creative Commons

By Brett Cottle ArtsHub | Monday, February 14, 2005

Brett Cottle, Chief Executive, of APRA – Australasian Performing Right Association has written to Arts Hub in response to a recent paper Arts Hub published by Dr Terry Cutler. Dr Cutler’s paper had been presented to a recent symposium on 'Open Content Licensing (OCL): Cultivating the Creative Commons', exploring the latest developments for the future of distributing, developing and negotiating rights in digital content. The aim of Creative Commons is to make copyright content more ‘active’ by ensuring that content can be re-utilised with a minimum of transactional effort.

Dr. Cutler is Company Director of Cutler and Company Pty Ltd - and works in new media, digital content, and creative industries. His paper looked at public policy issues the project is bringing to the fore. He is also the Chairman of The Dramatic Group Pty Ltd.

To view Dr Culter’s paper on Arts Hub visit: Creative Commons

In his response Brett Cottle said:

While no doubt an interesting contribution to the debate about the balancing of access to, and protection of, intellectual capital in Australia, Terry Cutler’s reasoning is at times difficult to follow.

Dr Cutler argues that there is a ‘systemic failure in public policy across the whole domain of innovation, investment in creative capital, and intellectual property’. This is a statement sufficiently grandiose to suggest the need for a little evidence; where is it? If, as it seems to be, it’s a statement about Australian conditions, some international comparative analysis might be useful.

In any event there seems to be a fundamental contradiction in the assertion. Evidence of innovation and investment in creative capital is usually measured by things such as numbers of patent applications, the number of books published, films made, records released etc. But these measurements would pose a problem in Dr Cutler’s reasoning, because on the one hand they would be regarded as evidence of a healthy level of innovation and creative output, but…..as everybody knows, they are also the likely consequence of a relatively high level of intellectual property protection. Which of course is exactly what Dr Cutler seems to be arguing against.

In support of the idea that there exists this ‘systemic failure’, it is argued that intellectual property ‘matters’ (ie, policy) are ‘carved out’ from trade policy and competition policy. This is at best a questionable assertion.

IP policy internationally was expressly brought into the international Trade Policy framework with the development of TRIPS in the early 1990s and has, if anything, been centre-stage in trade policy ever since. Indeed, it was my impression that the very complaint of the IP iconoclasts during the AUSFTA negotiations was that too much attention was paid to IP issues in the trade context.

Insofar as competition policy is concerned, the simple fact is that copyright law, patent law and other IP laws are subject in Australia to the Trade Practices Act. Therefore, to the extent that, for example, collecting societies run the risk of contravening competition law they have to apply for authorisation like anybody else. Such a process involves an exhaustive analysis not only of the activity of the applicant collecting society, but more importantly, of all relevant public interest considerations.

More generally, the intellectual property/competition policy interface has, if anything, undergone an unusually large number of examinations, both in high-profile public debate (the parallel import issue) and in expert reports (the Ergas report) in recent years. Where is the carve out?

The second big assertion in Dr Cutler’s paper is the ‘abnegation of public policy leadership’ [in intellectual property management?]. Unlike the first point in Dr Cutler’s paper, this seems to be a statement directed against governments around the world, because the abnegation has apparently been in favour of institutions ranging from the BBC to IBM. Maybe it’s a statement that is so big that it just can’t be answered. Maybe we’d be better off with the BBC running IP policy…it’s hard to say.

What can be said, I think is that there is surely nothing inherently undesirable about non-Government IP licensing initatives, nor indeed anything inconsistent in such developments with a proper legislative role being taken by Government.

New IP licensing models don’t necessarily require new laws; indeed, it might reasonably be argued that the ‘market’s’ ability to formulate new licensing models under existing laws is evidence of the effectiveness and flexibility of those laws. IP laws do not force inventors or authors into particular licensing models; they simply provide a legal basis upon which such a creator may choose if and how to license.

Included in Dr Cutler’s third point of public policy failure in intellectual property matters, ie the Australian Government’s failure to properly administer public content and ‘IP assets’ is criticism of the Government’s lack of proper regulation of collection societies. Simon Lake has pointed out a few facts in that connection, to which I add the comment that some societies, including APRA, have obtained or applied for ACCC authorization, which I can assure Dr Cutler is a very real form of Government supervision.

Brett Cottle
Chief Executive, Australasian Performing Right Association

Brett Cottle

Brett Cottle is the CEO of APRA (Australasian Performing Right Association). APRA is an association administering the rights of the world's composers, songwriters and publishers in Australia and New Zealand. Established in 1926, APRA represents in excess of 38,000 Australasian writers and publishers through direct membership, and nearly two million writers and publishers throughout the world under reciprocal, bilateral contracts.

E: editor@artshub.com.au
W: http://www.apra.com.au

Related news

A new term for the President of ACMI

A new term for the President of ACMI

ArtsHub (Australia) 3 Sep 2010

ACMI: The Australian Centre for the Moving Image has announced changes to its Board membership ...

Face the Music 2010

Face the Music 2010

ArtsHub (Not Selected) 3 Sep 2010

FACE THE MUSIC CONFERENCE: Early bird registrations for the third annual Face The Music ...

Local returns to manage Perth Arena

Local returns to manage Perth Arena

ArtsHub (Australia) 2 Sep 2010

AEG OGDEN: A Western Australian with more than 25 years experience in the venue management ...

New Media Art Award 2010 winner announced

New Media Art Award 2010 winner announced

ArtsHub (Australia) 31 Aug 2010

NEW MEDIA ART AWARD 2010: Premier Anna Bligh announced the Victorian artists Isobel Knowles and ...

Junction 2010: Connecting Regional Art Workers

Junction 2010: Connecting Regional Art Workers

Sarah Adams (Australia) 24 Aug 2010

JUNCTION 2010: Our cities can cast a shadow across artists in regional and remote communities ...

Berlin Dayz: You will be dazzled!

Berlin Dayz: You will be dazzled!

ArtsHub (Australia) 23 Aug 2010

BERLIN DAYZ: In celebration of the 20th anniversary of Germany’s reunification, the ...

Orana Arts Online Survey

Orana Arts Online Survey

ArtsHub (Australia) 20 Aug 2010

ORANA ARTS: Orana Arts is seeking feedback from the community on all aspects of its services and ...

A matter of global cohesion through the arts

A matter of global cohesion through the arts

ArtsHub (Australia) 20 Aug 2010

LA SALLE COLLEGE OF THE ARTS, SINGAPORE: The Australian Multicultural Foundation in partnership ...

ArtsPeak calls on Govt to protect arts funding

ArtsPeak calls on Govt to protect arts funding

ArtsHub (Australia) 18 Aug 2010

ARTSPEAK, the confederation of Australian national peak arts organisations, is calling on the ...

A good story

A good story

Ross Mueller (Australia) 11 Aug 2010

Simon Phillips is leaving the building. He has decided to walk into the sunset of the MTC at the ...

Sue Peacock: Dancer

Sue Peacock: Dancer

Arts Hub Australia (Australia) 12 May 2010

STRUT: As well as being a teacher, dancer and choreographer, Sue Peacock is the founding member ...

New Global Music omnibus travels HWY 101

New Global Music omnibus travels HWY 101

ArtsHub (Australia) 31 Aug 2009

Australia has embarked on an epic undertaking to generate more than 100 new musical works that ...

Nutcracker – The story of Clara: The Australian Ballet

Nutcracker – The story of Clara: The Australian Ba...

Chloe Smethurst (Australia) 12 Jun 2009

From the glamorous ballroom of the Russian Tsar to the dusty summer streets of Melbourne, Graeme ...

Chef's Special: The Spanish Film Festival 2009

Chef's Special: The Spanish Film Festival 2009

Mark Godfrey (Australia) 5 May 2009

Our protagonist in Chef’s Special - part of the Spanish Film Festival 2009 - is poor old gay Dad ...

Q150 Ideas festival program helps shape a dynamic future

Q150 Ideas festival program helps shape a dynamic ...

ArtsHub (Australia) 18 Feb 2009

Arts Minister Rod Welford has announced an innovative program of national and international ...

Record numbers compete for Asian Residencies

Record numbers compete for Asian Residencies

ArtsHub (Australia) 16 Feb 2009

A record number of applicants competed for 40 Asialink residencies in the fields of Arts ...

MUSIC REVIEW: Dawn Upshaw

MUSIC REVIEW: Dawn Upshaw

Edward Joyner (Australia) 5 Feb 2009

Australian Chamber Orchestra with Dawn Upshaw (soprano), Christopher Moore (viola) and Richard ...

Canberra Designers

Canberra Designers

www.canberratimes.com.au (Australia) 29 Jan 2009

The ACT boasts a thriving underground fashion industry and here, young designers show off samples of t...

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Anny Slater & Atonement Tonight

SYDNEY FESTIVAL: Anny Slater & Atonement Tonight

Emma Sorensen (Australia) 27 Jan 2009

Atonement Tonight is an animated comedy by Anny Slater about the 2006 Australian Wheat Board ...

Now look here: let's set the agenda for 2009

Now look here: let's set the agenda for 2009

The Guardian (United Kingdom) 27 Jan 2009

Next week, Liz Forgan takes over as chair of Arts Council England - at a time when the financial crisi...